# Contact info submission url: exile-blog.blogspot.com site_owner: address1: address2: city: state: country: postal_code: phone_number: display_email: site_name: site_description: The Exile

E-Mail Me

My Twitter

Top Blogs


Campaign 4 Public Ownership



Mothers For Justice

Ian Josephs

UKSecretCourt's Videos


Chris Paul

David Lindsay

Heresy Corner


Martin Meenagh

Neil Clark

Organised Rage

Renegade Eye

Serb Blog

Splintered Sunrise

Star of Vergina

Unrepentant Communist


British Politics

Censorship 01






New Britain 01

New Britain 02


Social Work Industry


Working Class

Atom Feed

XML Feed

28 August 2008
Why Harry's Place had to be supported
Following on from last night's posting, Harry's Place is now back on-line and no doubt feeling even more sanctimonious and self righteous than usual. The fact that many bloggers who normally could be expected to rally to this clear cut freedom of speech issue either ignored the events of the past 24 hours, or actually supported the attempt to knock HP off-line is something that should give HP pause for thought. Both Neil Clark and Lenin's Tomb were amongst those who just ignored the matter for most of the day, although the Tomb then posted on the matter late yesterday evening. That said, earlier in the day the Tomb's author did comment briefly on a forum, but only to let people know that HP was on its own. Other sites took the opportunity to stick the boot in by reminding people of just how one-sided the HP commitment to freedom of speech is. All in all, support for Harry's Place was nowhere near as total and solid as it should have been, given the attack that it had suffered.

Why so many people dislike HP is not hard to fathom, as the site is often little more than a smear machine disguised as a blog. When the machine decides to go after someone it uses all the talents that people thought had died with the late Dr. Josef Goebbels to try and discredit them. The aim, quite simply, is to stifle debate around certain issues by trying to discredit their proponents.

Jenna Delich had to misfortune to become a victim of the smear machine, so let's look at what happened to her in more detail. As we pointed out yesterday, she sent out a link to an article by a Joe Quinn that had been reposted on David Duke's site, to a University and College Union discussion board.

David T. of Harry's Place then felt able to headline his posting on the subject with the words "UCU and the David Duke fan". Nowhere in the text which followed is the allegation that Jenna Delich is a David Duke fan actually defended, but that doesn't matter because the smear is in. Just to make sure that the more bovine readers get the message, the lie is told that the Joe Quinn article only appeared on the Duke site, thus "It is therefore reasonable to infer that Jenna Delich reads and takes her information on world events from neo Nazis." Actually, the Quinn article was first posted on his own site, and then reposted by Duke as well as a few others, but to admit to that would make the neo-Nazi smear meaningless - even the readers of Harry's Place would be able to work that out - so it was better to offer up a small porkie in the hope that nobody would check.

Next, the machine posted a photo of Jenna, with the sub-heading "Sheffield-based academic, Jenna Delich - links to far right websites associated with the Ku Klux Klan". The fact that la Delich had linked to an article via one website had suddenly become "links" to "websites," but that is par for the smear machine's course.

Finally, the smear machine gave out just enough information about Jenna Delich so that its stooges who had bought into the smear that she was a "David Duke fan" who only "takes her information... from neo-Nazis," and who "links to far-right websites," could take over. It is now being reported that Jenna Delich has received hate mail and death threats. Of course that is not the fault of Harry's Place. They did not tell people to do that. Harry's Place doesn't do that - all it does is set the stage.

The Harry's Place smear machine has past form at all these noxious activities. Neil Clark can testify that the readers of Harry's Place were encouraged with a nod and a wink to write to the Guardian with a view to getting him sacked. Johann Hari knows that Harry's Place accused him of "making things up". That latter comment was deleted following a threat of legal action, but it was up long enough to serve its purpose. The stooges then took over and spread the smear far and wide.

So, on the basis of freedom of speech, your friendly old Exile has been forced to defend a blog that makes shit up about people with cavalier abandon and then sits back whilst its brain-dead readership tries to either intimidate them, get them to lose their jobs, or both at the same time.

Harry's Place do not deserve anyone's sympathy, but we do have to stand by that gleaming principle that debate should be free and open to anyone who can work a keyboard. For that reason alone Harry's Place had to be supported, even though by their smears they were trying to deny that freedom to others.

That simple truth sticks in this writer's throat as well as making his piles itch, but it doesn't alter the fact that the principle had to be defended.

Labels: ,


It sounds like six of one and half a dozen of the other to me. HP wanted to do over this Jenna, so she got the retaliation in first.

28 August 2008 at 12:21  

There is a rumour that I have just picked up, probably at about the same time as you were leaving your comment, that HP and Jenna Delich were actually in on this together. That it was a profile raising exercise for them both.

The tale has a certain charm to it, if you think about it. HP is now a source of income for its crew, and that's why they set up the arts section, to give them more advertising space. The problem is that you need punters coming in like billy-oh, otherwise you don't make shit. For HP this affair has certainly given them lots of attention.

Jenna? Dunno - raise her activist profile, get her known as the bird who did over HP for a day? I can imagine the offers coming in for her to speak at this or that gathering - all expenses paid, of course.

I'll be honest with you, mate. The reason why I made such a fuss today was that I knew that it would bring in new punters to the Exile. Has and all, you wanna see my hit counter.

Is it possible that I am not the only cynical old sod involved in this? Wouldn't that be a laugh?

28 August 2008 at 12:44  

It makes sense for that to have happened. I am not saying that they did, mind, but it does make sense.

You can't trust anyone these days.

28 August 2008 at 21:25  

You will never be able to prove it, but it has the ring of truth about it. Why did she go after the name server and not the ISP? If you do a Google for HP and Jenna Delich then they are being talked about all over the web.

No smoke without fire. You should investigate this one.

28 August 2008 at 23:22  

Thinking on a bit more, helped by several pints, do you reckon that it was more a case of each taking advantage of an opportunity, rather than getting involved in an organised operation?

Think about it. The girl posted a link and HP ran with the story. That gave the girl and HP the start of the publicity. Then she replies by going after HP, but doesn't screw over their ISP, which would have taken days to sort out, she just hits their name server.

It just looks to me more and more as if they were not actually in it together, but each was careful not to damage the other too much. Not a full conspiracy, just a bit of mutual back scratching.

29 August 2008 at 02:14  

In case you haven't known it, Joe Quinn, the author of the article that Delich linked to, has posted a response. The plot just thickens!!!

31 August 2008 at 12:27  

For you maybe, but for me it's over.

1 September 2008 at 07:09  

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home